Wednesday, December 30, 2015

Attention spans and deficits

ירושלמי ברכות פרק ב סוף הל' ד
א"ר חייא רובא אנא מן יומי לא כוונית אלא חד זמן בעי מכוונה והרהרית בלבי ואמרית מאן עליל קומי מלכא קדמי ארקבסה אי ריש גלותא.   
שמואל אמר אנא מנית אפרוחיא   
רבי בון בר חייא אמר אנא מנית דימוסיא   
א"ר מתניה אנא מחזק טיבו לראשי דכד הוה מטי מודים הוא כרע מגרמיה 

 Yerushalmi Berachot 2:4

Ribbi Hiya said, "I never got a chance to remain attentive during my prayers. One time, I really tried to focus. Instead, however, all I could do is wonder who walks into the king's office first when they go to visit him: the prime minister or the head of the Jewish community (Resh Galuta)."

Shemuel said, "I would absentmindedly count the birds fluttering around during my tefila."

Ribbi Bon bar Hiya said, "I would absentmindedly count the rows of brick in the nearest wall."

Ribbi Matnia said, "I am ever so grateful to my head, for when I reach Modim in my tefila, it bows on my behalf."

A"A would emphasize from here that maintaining focus during tefila is not an easy task at all. It is something that even the amoraim would struggle with at times. However, according to Halacha, it is absolutely necessary to at the very least say the first beracha of amida with proper attention and focus.
May HB"H grant us the ability to remain attentive for all our tefilot in the merit of the limmud Torah we just accomplished by learning this Yerushalmi. 

Tuesday, December 15, 2015

Good wine, nice beaches, and Limmud Torah

שבת קמז:
רבי אלעזר בן ערך איקלע להתם (עיר שהיה שם יין טוב וים יפה, ויכול להיות שהתכוונו על מיאמי) אימשיך בתרייהו איעקר תלמודיה כי הדר אתא קם למיקרי בספרא בעא למיקרא (שמות יב) "החדש הזה לכם." אמר "החרש היה לבם" בעו רבנן רחמי עליה והדר תלמודיה והיינו דתנן ר' נהוראי אומר הוי גולה למקום תורה ואל תאמר שהיא תבא אחריך שחבריך יקיימוה בידך ואל בינתך אל תשען
Shabbat 147b (Loosely translated)
Ribbi Elazar b. Arach traveled to a city known for its good wine and beautiful beaches, but which had no Torah. He was drawn after these pleasures, and as a result, forgot all of his limmud. When he returned from his vacation, they called him up to the sefer Torah for an aliya. His pasuk started off, "hachodesh haze lachem", but he could no longer differentiate between letters like כ and ב or ד and ר and read instead, "hacheresh haya libam" His peers prayed that God might have mercy on him, and he regained his Torah. 
This is why R. Nehorai taught in a mishnah: It is preferable for someone to exile himself to a place of Torah than to sit around and wait for the Torah to find him. A person cannot assume that having friends that are knowledgeable or that being bright will save him from ignorance. 
When A"A shares this gemara, he emphasizes the fact that Ribbi Elazar b. Arach wasn't just some nobody- he was one of the tana'im. Nevertheless, by focusing his attention on the pleasures of life, even if they are within the realms of halacha, like good wine and nice beaches, he neglected his Torah to such an extreme that he forgot how to read. How much more so must we be cautious that the focus of our attention always remains Torah, and that we take an active role in educating ourselves. A passive attitude will not only restrict our growth, but will reduce us to ignorance. 

Monday, December 7, 2015

Talmudic Pharmaceuticals

שבת דף קח:
שלח ליה רבי ינאי למר עוקבא: לישדר לן מר מהנך קילורין דמר שמואל! - שלח ליה: שדורי משדרנא לך, דלא תימא צר עין אנא. אלא הכי אמר שמואל: טובה טיפת צונן שחרית, ורחיצת ידים ורגלים בחמין ערבית, מכל קילורין שבעולם

Shabbat 108b

Rav Yanai once sent a letter to Mar Ukva requesting some Kilurin, a medicinal plant from the times of the Talmud, which was made popular by Shemuel.
He responded, "Attached, please find several grams of Kilurin. However, I only sent them so that you won't think that I'm a cheap jerk. Shemuel already told us, 'Good hygiene does more for one's health than all the Kilurin in the world!'"

Please, on behalf of all of humanity, and at least out of respect for Shemuel, wash your hands after you use the restroom! 

Monday, November 30, 2015

Unpopular names and dirty mustaches

יומא פג: 
ר"מ ור' יהודה ור' יוסי הוו קא אזלי באורחא ר' מאיר הוה דייק בשמא ר' יהודה ור' יוסי לא הוו דייקו בשמא כי מטו לההוא דוכתא בעו אושפיזא יהבו להו אמרו לו מה שמך אמר להו כידור אמר ש"מ אדם רשע הוא שנאמר (דברים לב) כי דור תהפוכות המה ר' יהודה ור' יוסי אשלימו ליה כיסייהו ר"מ לא אשלים ליה כיסיה אזל אותביה בי קיבריה דאבוה אתחזי ליה בחלמיה תא שקיל כיסא דמנח ארישא דההוא גברא למחר אמר להו הכי אתחזי לי בחלמאי אמרי ליה חלמא דבי שמשי לית בהו ממשא אזל ר"מ ונטריה כולי יומא ואייתיה למחר אמרו לו הב לן כיסן אמר להו לא היו דברים מעולם אמר להו ר"מ אמאי לא דייקיתו בשמא אמרו ליה אמאי לא אמרת לן מר אמר להו אימר דאמרי אנא חששא אחזוקי מי אמרי משכוהו ועיילוהו לחנותא חזו טלפחי אשפמיה אזלו ויהבו סימנא לדביתהו ושקלוהו לכיסייהו ואייתו אזל איהו וקטליה לאיתתיה היינו <דתנן> [דתניא] מים ראשונים האכילו בשר חזיר מים אחרונים הרגו את הנפש ולבסוף הוו דייקי בשמא כי מטו לההוא ביתא דשמיה בלה לא עיילו לגביה אמרי שמע מינה רשע הוא דכתיב (יחזקאל כג) ואמר לבלה נאפים 

Yoma 83b (loose translation, my own)

Ribbi Meir, Ribbi Yehuda, and Ribbi Yosse used to travel together. R' Meir had a habit of judging people based on their names, and R' Yehuda and R' Yosse did not. One day, they stopped in some city and checked into a local inn.
"What's your name?" They asked the concierge.
"Kidor," he told them.
R' Meir didn't trust him, because of the pasuk in Devarim that says, "For a generation (Ki Dor) of uprising they are, children who you can't trust."
R' Yehuda and R' Yosse entrusted him with their cash over shabbat, and R' Meir did not. Instead, he went and buried his wallet in the graveyard. He happened to bury it, however, right by Kidor's father's grave. That night, Kidor dreamt that his father was telling him to come take the cash buried near his head. Spooked out by the dream, he asked his rabbi guests what to make of it. R' Meir quickly assured him that dreams are meaningless and that there is no cash in the graveyard. As soon as he convinced Kidor to stay home, he ran to the cemetery to look after his hidden wallet so he can dig it up as soon as shabbat was over.
The next day, as they were checking out, the rabbis asked Kidor for the money they deposited with him.
"Money?" said Kidor. "What money? I know not of this money about which you speak!"
"What did you expect from a guy named Kidor?" R' Meir teased them.
"Why didn't you warn us?!" they asked R' Meir.
"Well, when it comes to names, nothing is for sure. I didn't want to spread rumors about this guy over a hunch."
As they were checking out, they noticed that some of the lentils which Kidor had for breakfast were still stuck in his mustache. They were suddenly inspired with a plan. After they left the motel, they stopped by Kidor's home and had a talk with his wife.
"Hey, you know that cash that your husband brought home last night?" They told her. "We're here to pick it up!"
"Okay," she responded, "but how do I know that my husband really sent you?"
"He told us to tell you that this morning you had lentils for breakfast instead of what normal people eat for breakfast."
On the grounds of this sign, she gave them the cash. When Kidor came home and saw what his wife had done, he beat her to death. About this incident the berayta states, "(Not washing up before a meal caused someone to eat pig, and) not washing up after the meal caused someone's death." (Others tell the story that he divorced her, Hullin 106a.)
From this moment on, all three of them were quick to judge people based on their names.

The moral of the story is always wash your hands and mustache after you eat, especially if you're planning on ripping someone off that day.
(On a slightly more serious note, Rabbenu Avraham b. haRambam says in his monograph on aggada that the moral of the story is that our rabbis were so smart that they could outfox all the jerks that tried to rip them off.)

Paternal Care

ירושלמי יומא ב:א
מעשה באחד שקדם את חבירו בתוך ארבע אמות של מזבח נטל חבירו את הסכין ותקעה בלבו עמד לו ר' צדוק על מעלת האולם אמר להן שמעוני אחי בית ישראל כתיב (דברים טז) כי ימצא חלל וגו' ויצאו זקיניך ושופטיך אנו מאיכן לנו למוד מן ההיכל מן העזרות שרון כל עמא בכיין עד דאינון עסיקין בבכייה נכנס אביו של אותו התינוק אמר להן אני כפרתכם אדיין התינוק מפרפר ולא ניטמאת הסכין מלמד שהיתה טומאה קשה להן משפיכות דמים לגנאי 

Yerushalmi Yoma 2:1 (loosely translated, my own)

It had once occurred that a Cohen beat his friend to the mizbe'ach to perform a service in the Bet haMikdash. His friend (some friend this guy was...) pulled out a knife and stabbed him in the heart so he can get there first.
Appalled, R' Tzadok climbed to the steps of the Temple and yelled at the crowd. He said, "By an Egla Arufa, the Torah commands out to measure the distance between the corpse and the nearest cities. From where should we measure, from the Temple itself or from the Courtyard?"
In other words, he was upset that they were so desensitized to murder that it occurred on the Temple grounds itself and nobody seemed to flinch.
The crowd accepted his rebuke and began to sob.
While they were busy sobbing, the father of the victim came and saw the commotion. He turned to the Cohanim and said, "Don't worry, I will be your atonement. In the meantime, get back to work! The boy is still in the throes of death and therefore the knife you used is not yet impure!"
Unfortunately, these people viewed ritual purity with higher regard than murder.

I'm still not sure who takes home the Worst Father in the Talmud award, this guy, or the father from this next story:

חולין צד. 
ואין האורחין רשאין ליתן ממה שלפניהם לבנו ולבתו של בעה"ב אא"כ נטלו רשות מבעה"ב ומעשה באחד שזמן ג' אורחין בשני בצורת ולא היה לו להניח לפניהם אלא כשלש ביצים בא בנו של בעה"ב נטל אחד מהן חלקו ונתנו לו וכן שני וכן שלישי בא אביו של תינוק מצאו שעוזק א' בפיו ושתים בידו חבטו בקרקע ומת כיון שראתה אמו עלתה לגג ונפלה ומתה אף הוא עלה לגג ונפל ומת א"ר אליעזר בן יעקב על דבר זה נהרגו ג' נפשות מישראל 

Hullin 94a (loosely translated, my own again)

Guests at a meal may not share their food with the children of the host without permission. It once happened that during a famine, a host invited 3 people to dinner at his home. All he had to offer them was three rolls, each the size of an egg. The host stepped out for a moment, and the son of the host happened to walk by the table. Each guest gave his share of bread to the child. The dad came by, saw his son with a roll in his mouth and one in each hand, and was so upset that he beat his child to death. When the mother of this child saw what had happened, she threw herself off the roof. He soon followed suit.

A story that not even Edgar Allan Poe could top.  

Thursday, November 19, 2015

Ditching Rav Hasda's Shiur

שבת פב. 
אמר ליה רב הונא לרבה בריה מאי טעמא לא שכיחת קמיה דרב חסדא דמחדדן שמעתיה אמר ליה מאי איזיל לגביה דכי אזילנא לגביה מותיב לי במילי דעלמא אמר לי מאן דעייל לבית הכסא לא ליתיב בהדיא ולא ליטרח טפי דהאי כרכשתא אתלת שיני יתיב דילמא משתמטא שיני דכרכשתא ואתי לידי סכנה א"ל הוא עסיק בחיי דברייתא ואת אמרת במילי דעלמא כ"ש זיל לגביה 

Shabbat 82a

Rav Huna once asked his son Rabbah, "Why do you ditch Rav Hasda's shiur? He's so sharp! Don't you want to learn from him?"
Rabba answered, "But dad, what's the point? Every time I go to class, he ends up talking about nonsense! He tells us, "When you're in the bathroom, tone down the intensity or you're going to get hemorrhoids!'"
Rav Huna reprimanded his son, "He's teaching you medicinal practices and you dismiss it as 'nonsense'?! These are the most important kinds of things you can learn from him! From now on, you definitely have to go!"

From here A"A proves that learning Rambam's Hil' De'ot is considered limmud Torah, and is perhaps even more important. 

Tuesday, November 17, 2015

Would you trust Rav Ashe with 10 Zuz?

בבא מציעא עה: 
אמר רב יהודה אמר רב כל מי שיש לו מעות ומלוה אותן שלא בעדים עובר משום ולפני עור לא תתן מכשול וריש לקיש אמר גורם קללה לעצמו שנאמ' (תהילים לא) תאלמנה שפתי שקר הדוברות על צדיק עתק אמרו ליה רבנן לרב אשי קא מקיים רבינא כל מה דאמור רבנן שלח ליה בהדי פניא דמעלי שבתא לישדר לי מר עשרה זוזי דאתרמי לי קטינא דארעא למזבן שלח ליה ניתי מר סהדי ונכתב כתבא שלח ליה אפילו אנא נמי שלח ליה כל שכן מר דטריד בגירסיה משתלי וגורם קללה לעצמי 

Bava Metsia 75b (loose translation, my own, slightly embellished)

 Rav Yehuda said in the name of Rav that anyone who lends money without witnesses transgresses the prohibition of enabling someone else to sin (because he leaves him opportunity to lie and deny the loan). Resh Lakish said that someone who does this brings a curse upon himself.

One day, the Rabbanim asked Rav Ashe, "Does Ravina adhere to everything that the Sages enacted?"
To test him out, Rav Ashe sent him a message one Erev Shabbat, "I came across a sweet deal on some land, can you lend me 10 Zuz to purchase it?"
Ravina answered, "Sure, draft up a contract and send over some witnesses and I'll be glad to!"
Rav Ashe sent back, "Even for me?! (Do you think I'm going to rip you off or something?)"
Ravina answered, "Especially or you! You're so busy filling that big brain of yours with Torah knowledge that it'll slip your mind, and I'll end up with Resh Lakish's curse!"

Seems like Ravina had a diplomatic answer for everything.
 
 

Monday, November 16, 2015

Don't mess with Ribbi Yohanan

בבא קמא קיז.
ההוא גברא דהוה בעי אחוויי אתיבנא דחבריה אתא לקמיה דרב א"ל לא תחוי ולא תחוי א"ל מחוינא ומחוינא יתיב רב כהנא קמיה דרב שמטיה לקועיה מיניה קרי רב עילויה (ישעיהו נא) בניך עולפו שכבו בראש כל חוצות כתוא מכמר מה תוא זה כיון שנפל במכמר אין מרחמין עליו אף ממון של ישראל כיון שנפל ביד <עובדי כוכבים> {גוים} אין מרחמין עליו א"ל רב כהנא עד האידנא הוו פרסאי דלא קפדי אשפיכות דמים והשתא איכא [רומאי] דקפדו אשפיכות דמים ואמרי מרדין מרדין קום סק לארעא דישראל וקביל עלך דלא תקשי לרבי יוחנן שבע שנין אזיל אשכחיה לריש לקיש דיתיב וקא מסיים מתיבתא דיומא לרבנן אמר להו ריש לקיש היכא אמרו ליה אמאי אמר להו האי קושיא והאי קושיא והאי פירוקא והאי פירוקא אמרו ליה לריש לקיש אזל ריש לקיש א"ל לרבי יוחנן ארי עלה מבבל לעיין מר במתיבתא דלמחר למחר אותבוה בדרא קמא קמיה דר' יוחנן אמר שמעתתא ולא אקשי שמעתתא ולא אקשי אנחתיה אחורי שבע דרי עד דאותביה בדרא בתרא א"ל רבי יוחנן לר"ש בן לקיש ארי שאמרת נעשה שועל אמר יהא רעוא דהני שבע דרי להוו חילוף שבע שנין דאמר לי רב קם אכרעיה א"ל נהדר מר ברישא אמר שמעתתא ואקשי אוקמיה בדרא קמא אמר שמעתתא ואקשי ר' יוחנן הוה יתיב אשבע בסתרקי שלפי ליה חדא בסתרקא מתותיה אמר שמעתתא ואקשי ליה עד דשלפי ליה כולהו בסתרקי מתותיה עד דיתיב על ארעא רבי יוחנן גברא סבא הוה ומסרחי גביניה אמר להו דלו לי עיני ואחזייה דלו ליה במכחלתא דכספא חזא דפרטיה שפוותיה סבר אחוך קמחייך ביה חלש דעתיה ונח נפשיה למחר אמר להו רבי יוחנן לרבנן חזיתו לבבלאה היכי עביד אמרו ליה דרכיה הכי על לגבי מערתא חזא דהוה
 הדרא ליה עכנא א"ל עכנא עכנא פתח פומיך ויכנס הרב אצל תלמיד ולא פתח יכנס חבר אצל חבר ולא פתח יכנס תלמיד אצל הרב פתח ליה בעא רחמי ואוקמיה א"ל אי הוה ידענא דדרכיה דמר הכי לא חלשא דעתי השתא ליתי מר בהדן א"ל אי מצית למיבעי רחמי דתו לא שכיבנא אזילנא ואי לא לא אזילנא הואיל וחליף שעתא חליף תייריה אוקמיה שייליה כל ספיקא דהוה ליה ופשטינהו ניהליה היינו דאמר ר' יוחנן דילכון אמרי דילהון היא:


Bava Kama 117a (Soncino Press translation)
A certain man who was desirous of showing another man's straw [to be confiscated] appeared before Rab, who said to him: 'Don't show it! Don't show it!' He retorted: 'I will show it! I will show it!' R. Kahana was then sitting before Rab, and he tore [that man's] windpipe out of him [in a martial-arts-like manner]. Rab thereupon quoted: Thy sons have fainted, they lie at the heads of all the streets as a wild bull in a net;  just as when a 'wild bull' falls into a 'net' no one has mercy upon it, so with the property of an Israelite, as soon as it falls into the hands of heathen oppressors no mercy is exercised towards it.35  Rab therefore said to him: 'Kahana, until now the [Persians]  who did not take much notice of bloodshed were [here and had sway, but] now the [Romans]  who are particular regarding bloodshed are here, and they will certainly say, "Murder, murder!";  arise therefore and go up to the Land of Israel but take it upon yourself that you will not point out any difficulty to R. Johanan  for the next seven years. When he arrived there he found Resh Lakish sitting and going over  the lecture of the day for [the younger of] the Rabbis.  He thereupon said to them: 'Where is Resh Lakish?'  They said to him: 'Why do you ask?' He replied: 'This point [in the lecture] is difficult and that point is difficult, but this could be given as an answer and that could be given as an answer.' When they mentioned this to Resh Lakish, Resh Lakish went and said to R. Johanan: 'A lion  has come up from Babylon; let the Master therefore look very carefully into tomorrow's lecture.' On the morrow R. Kahana was seated on the first row of disciples before R. Johanan, but as the latter made one statement and the former did not raise any difficulty, another statement, and the former raised no difficulty, R. Kahana was put back through the seven rows until he remained seated upon the very last row. R. Johanan thereupon said to R. Simeon b. Lakish: 'The lion you mentioned turns out to be a [mere] fox.'  R. Kahana thereupon  whispered [in prayer]: 'May it be the will [of Heaven] that these seven rows be in the place of the seven years mentioned by Rab.' He thereupon immediately stood on his feet  and said to R. Johanan: 'Will the Master please start the lecture again from the beginning.' As soon as the latter made a statement [on a matter of law], R. Kahana pointed out a difficulty, and so also when R. Johanan subsequently made further statements, for which he was placed again on the first row. R. Johanan was sitting upon seven cushions. Whenever he made a statement against which a difficulty was pointed out, one cushion was pulled out from under him, [and so it went on until] all the cushions were pulled out from under him and he remained seated upon the ground. As R. Johanan was then a very old man and his eyelashes were overhanging he said to them, 'Lift up my eyes for me as I want to see him.' So they lifted up his eye[lashes] with silver pincers. He saw that R. Kahana's lips were parted  and thought that he was laughing at him. He felt aggrieved and in consequence the soul of R. Kahana went to rest.  On the next day R. Johanan said to our Rabbis, 'Have you noticed how the Babylonian was making [a laughing-stock of us]?' But they said to him, 'This was his natural appearance.' [Rav Kahana was not laughing at Ribbi Yohanan, he was simply funny-looking.] He thereupon went to the cave [of R. Kahana's grave] and saw a snake coiled round it. He said: 'Snake, snake, open thy mouth  and let the Master go in to the disciple.' But the snake did not open its mouth. He then said: 'Let the colleague go in to [his] associate!' But it still did not open [its mouth, until he said,] 'Let the disciple enter to his Master,' when the snake did open its mouth.  He then prayed for mercy and raised him.  He said to him, 'Had I known that the natural appearance of the Master was like that, I should never have taken offence; now, therefore let the Master go with us.' He replied, 'If you are able to pray for mercy that I should never die again [through causing you any annoyance],  I will go with you, but if not I am not prepared to go with you. For later on you might change again.' R. Johanan thereupon completely awakened and restored him and he used to consult him on doubtful points, R. Kahana solving them for him. This is implied in the statement made by R. Johanan: 'What  I had believed to be yours  was In fact theirs.

A"A compared this gemara to the story of the death of Rish Lakish (recorded in Bava Metsia, 84a), also at the hands of Ribbi Yohanan's hak'pada. Don't mess with Ribbi Yohanan. 

Sunday, October 11, 2015

Man's Best Friend

תלמוד ירושלמי מסכת תרומות פרק ח הלכה ג
חד בר נש זמין חד רבן ואייתיב כלבא גביה א"ל ביזיון אנא חייב לך א"ל ר' טיבו אנא משלם ליה שביין עלון לקרתא עאל חד מינהון בעא מינסב איתתי ואכל ביציו

Yerushalmi Terumot 8:3

There once was a man who invited an esteemed Rabbi over to his home. When he was seating his guests, he seated his pet Doberman Pinscher next to the Rabbi.
Appalled, the Rabbi asked, "Do I owe you money or something that you're treating me with such offense?"
"No k'vod harav, you got it all wrong!" the host replied. "I am not trying to show disrespect to you, but rather respect to my dog. Yesterday, there was a kidnapping attempt on my wife, but my dog saved the day by ripping off the thug's testicles!"

Wednesday, September 30, 2015

Goats and Gangsters


בבא קמא פ. 
ת"ר מעשה בחסיד אחד שהיה גונח מלבו ושאלו לרופאים ואמרו אין לו תקנה עד שינק חלב רותח משחרית לשחרית והביאו לו עז וקשרו לו בכרעי המטה והיה יונק ממנה משחרית לשחרית לימים נכנסו חביריו לבקרו כיון שראו אותה העז קשורה בכרעי המטה חזרו לאחוריהם ואמרו לסטים מזויין בביתו של זה ואנו נכנסין אצלו?!
Bava Kama 80a:

It was taught: there once was a pious person who had a heart condition. He sought instruction from the physicians and was told that the only remedy was to drink fresh milk each morning. They brought him a goat and tied it to his nightstand and he would drink from its milk each morning. A few days later, his peers came to visit him. When they saw the goat tied to his nightstand, they backed out slowly and said, "this house is full of gangsters and we're expected to come in?"

Abusing the gift of forgetfulness

דברים לב:יח 
צוּר יְלָדְךָ, תֶּשִׁי;  וַתִּשְׁכַּח, אֵל מְחֹלְלֶךָ
 Devarim 32:18 
God has granted you the ability to forget, but you have forgotten God himself
Forgetfulness is a gift. Were we to remember every detail of our lives, we would be unable to function efficiently. We would be constantly torn by sorrow and grief, eaten away by guilt, and weighed down with responsibility. In Parashat Ha'azinu, however, Moshe Rabbenu complains that we abused this gift and forgot our Creator who provided it to us in the first place.

The Maggid Midovno illustrates this with the following mashal, which my father likes to share from time to time:

In a time before credit scores and collection agencies, there lived a man who was deep in debt. Unable to pay back his loans, he turned to a friend for help.
"Just feign insanity and they'll leave you alone," his friend advised. "When they come to collect their money, start singing as loud as you can. Your debtors will think you've lost your mind and they'll leave you alone."
That night, an angry mob banged on his door.
"Where's our money?!" They shouted at him.
Bearing in mind what his friend told him earlier, he broke out in song: "LALALALALALALA!"
His debtors concluded that the stress must have addled his brain and abandoned hope of getting their money back.
Later that year, short on cash once more, this man turned to his friend, who had advised him earlier, for some money. He promised profusely that he will repay the loan in a timely fashion. The friend reluctantly handed over $100.
A week passed, and then another. There was no sign of the debtor or the $100 that he owed. Upset, the friend knocked on his door a few days later, hoping to get his money back.
As soon as the man saw his friend by the door, he broke out into song: "LALALALALALALA!"
"Idiot!" his (former) friend shouted. "I taught you that trick! You can't use it against me!"

Hashem graced us with the gift of forgetfulness, but sometimes, as the pasuk attests, we use it against Him and forget Him and His grace. 

Sunday, September 20, 2015

Talmudic Mention of Radio Waves?

.יומא דף כ: - כא

ת"ר שלש קולות הולכין מסוף העולם ועד סופו ואלו הן קול גלגל חמה וקול המונה של רומי וקול נשמה בשעה שיוצאה מן הגוף וי"א אף לידה ויש אומרים אף רידייא ובעו רבנן רחמי אנשמה בשעה שיוצאה מן הגוף ובטלוה
 Yoma 20b- 21a (Soncino Press Translation)
Our Rabbis taught: There are three sounds going from one end of the world to the other: The sound of the revolution of the sun; the sound of the tumult of Rome, and the sound of the soul as it leaves the body. Some say also the sound of childbirth and some say also the sound of Ridya [radio??]. The Sages prayed for the soul as it leaves the body and achieved the stopping [of that cry].
Avi uMori sometimes quotes this berayta as a suggestion that perhaps the Talmud predicted radio waves 1,700 years before they were formally discovered. He often quotes Bechorot 57b along with it, which may be a prediction of atomic missiles.

Ribbi Yishmael: Finding Beauty in Congruence

Nedarim 66b:

ההוא דאמר לה לדביתהו "קונם שאי את נהנית לי עד שתראי מום יפה שביך לר' ישמעאל בר' יוסי"
אמר להם: "שמא ראשה נאה?"
אמרו לו: "סגלגל"
"שמא שערה נאה?"
"דומה לאניצי פשתן"
"שמא עיניה נאות?"
" טרוטות הן"
"שמא אזניה נאות?"
"כפולות הן"
"שמא חוטמה נאה?"
"בלום הוא"
"שמא שפתותיה נאות?"
"עבות הן"
"שמא צוארה נאה?"
"שקוט הוא"
"שמא כריסה נאה?"
"צבה הוא"
"שמא רגליה נאות?"
"רחבות כשל אווזא"
"שמא שמה נאה?"
"לכלוכית שמה"
אמר להן: "יפה קורין אותה לכלוכית שהיא מלוכלכת במומין" ושרייה

Translation (paraphrased with help from Artscroll):
There was a guy who said to his wife, "I want us to separate until R' Yishmael finds something attractive about you!"
R' Yishmael suggested: "Maybe her head is nice?"
He was told: "Her head is as round as a ball."
"Maybe she has nice hair?"
"It's as disheveled as flax."
"Maybe her eyes are nice?"
"They're too wide."
"Maybe her ears are nice?"
"They're twice as big as they should be."
"Maybe her nose is nice?"
"It's all smashed up."
"Maybe her lips are nice?
"They're thick and swollen."
"Maybe she has a nice neck?"
"It's too short."
"Maybe she has a good figure?"
"She's a fatty."
"Maybe her feet are nice?"
"She has duck-feet."
"Does she at least have a pretty name?"
"Her name is 'Nasty'"
He responded: "How beautifully does her name match her! What congruence!"
Her husband took her back.

Introductory Statement


אבות ה:טו

ארבע מידות ביושבי לפני חכמים--ספוג, ומשפך, משמרת, ונפה:  ספוג, שהוא סופג את הכול; משפך--שהוא מכניס בזו, ומוציא בזו; משמרת--שהיא מוציאה את היין, וקולטת את השמרים; ונפה--שהיא מוציאה את הקמח, וקולטת את הסולת
Avot 5:15

There are four types of listeners: "The sponge" absorbs everything, "the funnel" takes it in from one ear and lets it out the other, "the wine filter" (mashmeret) lets the good stuff through and retains only the junk, and "the sifter" lets the nonsense fall through and holds on to the best.

The intent of this blog is to share not wine but sediment: content-less bits of Torah which inevitably slip into limmud. Over my time studying under Avi uMori, I have occasioned to document some of the stories, jokes, and comical remarks in the Talmud and elsewhere with which our limmud is so rich and which keep the Talmidim awake and attentive. Be'ezrat Hashem, I hope to make them available here for any reader who wishes to enjoy them.

I'll start with a story my father is fond of sharing when certain speakers take the podium:

Once, in a small Ukrainian village, there was a member of the Jewish community with a bad habit of reporting on the community to the authorities. As a result, the Jewish members of the town wanted as little to do with him as possible. One year, he demanded of the Rabbi to allow him to act as ba'al toke'a on Rosh Hashana- to blow the Shofar for the whole Bet Kinesset to hear. The Rabbi refused, and the informant turned to the chief of police for help. The chief of police called in the Rabbi for questioning, and, trembling from head to toe, he came immediately.
The three of them sat down and the chief of police said, "Rabbi, my friend here says that you refuse to let him blow the shofar on Rosh Hashana. You wouldn't treat my good friend in such an ill manner, would you?"
"But, your honor," the Rabbi protested, "I suggested instead that he should blow shofar at the conclusion of our holiest day of the calendar, Yom Kippur!" (upon which hearing the shofar is not an actual mitzva).
The chief turned to his companion. "The Rabbi is right, Yom Kippur is definitely the most solemn day on your calendar. Why don't you want to blow on Yom Kippur instead?"
"No way!" The informer shouted. "He's trying to trick us! On Yom Kippur, we only blow one sound. On Rosh Hashana, we blow a hundred!"
"Idiot!" The police chief told him. "Once the shofar is in your hands, blow as many times as you want!"

Some speakers think that once the microphone is in their hands, they can speak for as long as they want. On that note, I will try to keep these posts short and sweet, and not waste away too much of the reader's precious time. I hope you enjoy these little sediments of the wine as much as I do.