Sunday, November 19, 2017

Gross Anatomy

בכורות דף מה ע"א
מעשה בתלמידיו של ר' ישמעאל ששלקו זונה אחת שנתחייבה שריפה למלך בדקו ומצאו בה מאתים וחמשים ושנים אמר להם שמא באשה בדקתם שהוסיף לה הכתוב שני צירים ושני דלתות
Bechorot 45a 
There was once a prostitute who was sentenced to death by the king. Her cadaver was given over to the students of Ribbi Yishmael to corrode and perform osteological studies. After studying her bones, they concluded that there were 252 bones, and not 248 like the Mishnah in Massechet Ohalot (1:9) claims! When they reported this discrepancy to their teacher, he asked them, "Was it a woman which you dissected? A woman's pelvis does not ossify in the same manner that a man's does!"

It is worth noting that according to today's anatomists, the adult human only has 206 bones. A"A addresses this by quoting the Encylopedia HaIvrit, which explains that the Talmudic account of 248 was not meant to be an account of complete bones but rather of ossification centers
I would like to add a suggestion. Perhaps the difference lies in the definition of adulthood: anatomical adulthood is defined by the completion of ossification (which occurs at around 20 years of age) while Halachic adulthood is defined as 12 or 13 years of age (for females and males respectively) or the onset of pubic hair growth (if it occurs after that age). Anatomists would agree that at 13 years of age, there are somewhere between 270 and 206 bones in the body.

Monday, November 13, 2017

Emotional Honesty


יומא דף סט ע"ב  
אמר רבי יהושע בן לוי: למה נקרא שמן אנשי כנסת הגדולה? שהחזירו עטרה ליושנה.
אתא משה אמר (דברים י) "האל הגדול הגבור והנורא" אתא ירמיה ואמר "נכרים מקרקרין בהיכלו איה נוראותיו?" לא אמר נורא.
אתא דניאל אמר "נכרים משתעבדים בבניו איה גבורותיו?" לא אמר גבור.
אתו אינהו ואמרו "אדרבה- זו היא גבורת גבורתו שכובש את יצרו שנותן ארך אפים לרשעים ואלו הן נוראותיו שאלמלא מוראו של הקב"ה היאך אומה אחת יכולה להתקיים בין האומות"
Yoma 69b 
Ribbi Yehoshua b. Levi said: Why were they called 'Men of the Great Assembly'? What was so great about them? It was because they reinstated God's glory. Moshe Rabbenu originally referred to Hashem as "HaEl HaGadol Hagibbor vehaNora- The Lord, the Great, the Mighty and the Awesome" (Devarim 10:17).
Yirmiyahu came around a few hundred years later and asked, "The enemy is frolicking around the holiest site of the Temple- where is Hashem's awesomeness?" In his description of Hashem, Yirmiyahu cut out the word "Nora" (Yirmiyahu 32:18).
Daniel came around a few years after that and asked, "The enemy is enslaving His children- where is Hashem's might?" In his description of Hashem, he cut out the word "Gibbor" (Daniel 9:4).
Came the Men of the Great Assembly and explained: Hashem's might is demonstrated by the fact that he restrains himself from intervening before the time is right. Hashem's awesomeness is demonstrated by the fact that he keeps his nation in existence even when scattered around the world. They reinstated the full phrase into our prayers- HaEl Hagadol Hagibbor vehaNora

The approach of Yirmiyahu and Daniel seems provocative at first- did they really deny that Hashem was Awesome or that he was Mighty? A"A explains as follows: Yirmiyahu and Daniel never doubted Hashem's traits for a minute. However, although they recognized them on an intellectual level, they were unable to feel them on an emotional level. They saw tragedy all around them, and they had trouble reconciling their experiences with what they knew to be true. And, although they knew it to be true on an intellectual level, they could not incorporate these phrases into their prayers because they could not relate to it on an emotional level. 
May we always experience intellectual and emotional honesty in our prayers and in every other way which we choose to relate to Hashem. 

Sunday, November 12, 2017

Who will build the Third Bet HaMikdash?

How the Third Temple will be constructed is an interesting topic of discussion, and hopefully one that will be relevant in the coming days. There are two main approaches, that of the Rambam, and that of Rash"i and Tosafot. 
The Rambam clearly believed that the responsibility of building the Third Temple lies among us, the Jewish people. He writes:
רמב"ם פ"א מהל' בית הבחירה הלכה א 
מִצְוַת עֲשֵׂה לַעֲשׂוֹת בַּיִת לַה', מוּכָן לִהְיוֹת מַקְרִיבִים בּוֹ הַקָּרְבָּנוֹת, וְחוֹגְגִין אֵלָיו שָׁלוֹשׁ פְּעָמִים בַּשָּׁנָה--שֶׁנֶּאֱמָר "וְעָשׂוּ לִי, מִקְדָּשׁ" (שמות כה,ח); וּכְבָר נִתְפָּרַשׁ בַּתּוֹרָה מִשְׁכָּן שֶׁעָשָׂה מֹשֶׁה רַבֵּנוּ, וְהָיָה לְפִי שָׁעָה--שֶׁנֶּאֱמָר "כִּי לֹא-בָאתֶם, עַד-עָתָּה . . ." (דברים יב,ט). 
Rambam Laws of the Temple 1:1 
It is a positive commandment to build a house for God, where sacrifices will be brought and holidays will be celebrated three times a year....
Likewise, the Rambam writes elsewhere:

הלכות מלכים ומלחמות פ' י"א הל' א 
 הַמֶּלֶךְ הַמָּשִׁיחַ עֲתִיד לַעֲמֹד, וּלְהַחְזִיר מַלְכוּת בֵּית דָּוִיד לְיָשְׁנָהּ הַמֶּמְשָׁלָה הָרִאשׁוֹנָה, וּבוֹנֵה מִקְדָּשׁ, וּמְקַבֵּץ נִדְחֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל. 
 Laws of Kings and of War 11:1  
The Melech HaMashiach will rise up, reinstate the Davidic dynasty and its original government, build the temple, and gather the people of Israel to their home.
There is, however, a second school of thought that believed that the third Temple will descend fully constructed out of the heavens. The responsibility to construct the next Bet HaMikdash lies not upon us but upon Hashem Himself. This is the opinion of Rash"i and the Tosafot (Succah 41a). This opinion is based of a collection of Midrashe Aggada, such as the following:
פסיקתא רבתי סי' כח 
אין נוטה עוד אהלי [ומקים יריעותי] (ירמיה י י), מהו, וכי אין בית המקדש עתיד ליבנות, אלא אין נוטה עוד אהלי מכם ואין מקים יריעותי מכם, אלא מקדש ראשון שבנאו בשר ודם נפל ביד שונא אבל מקדש אחרון שהקדוש ברוך הוא בונה אותו שנאמר בונה ירושלים ה' נדחי ישראל יכנס (תהלים קמ"ז ב') שוב לא יחרב לכך נאמר אהלי שודד וגו'. 
According to this opinion, the Bet Hamikdash will descend from the heaven constructed and assembled when the time is right. 
When asked to decide between the two opinions, A"A quotes the following opinion of Rav Yaakov Ettlinger (1798-1871):
ערוך לנר למסכת סוכה דף מא ע"א 
ולכן הי' נלענ"ד דודאי ביהמ"ק לעתיד לבא יבנה בנין ממש בידי אדם ומה שנאמר מקדש ד' כוננו ידיך שנדרש בתנחומא שירד למטה הוא ביהמ"ק רוחני שיבא לתוך ביהמ"ק הנבנה גשמי כנשמה בתוך הגוף וכמו שירד במשכן ובבית המקדש האש של מעלה תוך האש של הדיוט שנבער בעצים וכן נראה במכילתא דדרש מפסוק מכון לשבתך פעלת ד' שבית המקדש של מעלה מכוון כנגד בית המקדש של מטה ועל זה קאמר מקדש ד' כוננו ידיך שלעתיד לבא כשימלוך ד' לעולם ועד לעיני כל באי עולם ישכון למטה בתוך מקדש שכבר בנוי הוא ומכוון כנגד ביהמ"ק של מטה והיינו שירד למטה תוך המקדש שיבנה ועיין בזוהר פ' וישב שמשמע שם כן אמנם כמו שלמטה בארץ אין נשמה בלא גוף כמו כן המקדש רוחני לא יקום בלא מקדש גשמי ולכן א"ש הלשון בנין בביהמ"ק שלעתיד ג"כ 
Arukh Laner (Succah 41a)  
In my opinion, the physical building of third temple will definitely be constructed by mankind. The Midrashim that say that the Temple will be prepared by God and descend from heaven are referring to a spiritual Bet HaMikdash which will descend and occupy the physical Bet HaMikdash the way a soul occupies a physical body. This is akin to how a heavenly fire used to descend during times of the Mishkan and previous Bet HaMikdash into the flames that were kindled [by the Kohanim] on the Mizbeach......
In summary, this opinion combines the two- while the physical third Bet HaMikdash will be constructed by mankind, the spiritual aspect of it will descend from Heaven. We cannot wait around forever until a Temple falls out of the sky for us. We must do our part when the time comes, build the walls and the roof, and hope that Hashem accepts our construction and fills our building the spiritual aspect that it requires to function properly.